Best American Food Places in New York City
1. Pastrami Queen, New York City
Old-school kosher-style deli serving overstuffed pastrami sandwiches on rye bread. The space is small and unassuming; expect to squeeze in for a table.
$$
Old-school kosher-style deli serving overstuffed pastrami sandwiches on rye bread. The space is small and unassuming; expect to squeeze in for a table.
Historic Midtown dining room with deep red banquettes and monkey lamps glowing above the bar. A wraparound mural of Jazz Age icons lines the main room – look for Sinatra, Ellington, and Dorothy Parker.
Glamorous, burlesque-themed steakhouse defined by siren-red walls and vintage portraits of 1930s showgirls. The menu is pure classics – charred New York strips, shareable sides, and a towering 24-layer chocolate cake for dessert.
No-frills East Village counter slinging authentic Philly cheesesteaks on fresh-baked sesame rolls. The narrow space is standing-room-only – most people take their sandwiches across the street to Tompkins Square Park.
Bakery that turns the classic New York bagel into a self-contained meal, stuffing hand-rolled dough with savory fillings. The tiny Greenwich Village shop is built for takeout – grab a Pastrami Reuben and a coffee from the full espresso bar.
Grand, Art Deco dining room serving a French interpretation of steakhouse classics from a wood-burning grill. Expect tableside theatre – prime rib is carved from a rolling cart and Caesar salads are tossed to order.
Dimly lit sports tavern where locals watch the game from booths in the back. The kitchen serves smashed burgers and a BEC donut; the bar pours creative cocktails like the Irish Buck.
Fine-dining spot in Lincoln Center serving Afro-Caribbean dishes like braised oxtails and egusi dumplings. The stylish room runs on a 90s hip-hop soundtrack; a line for walk-ins forms daily at 4 pm.
Dual-concept cocktail bar where a back room serves drinks that taste like food – think Cold Pizza or Key Lime Pie. Its casual front room is for walk-ins, pouring tap cocktails and serving a standout hot honey fried chicken sandwich.
Stripped-down wine bar with a Brooklyn feel, pouring natural wines to an upbeat R&B soundtrack. The menu is creative small plates – the seared Arroz a la Plancha and whipped banana pudding are essential.
Opulent supper club with leopard-print carpets, red corduroy settees, and Murano glass chandeliers. Live jazz from a baby grand piano fills the room, accompanying classic cocktails and caviar served late.
Sunlit fast-casual spot serving neurologist-designed bowls and sandwiches for brain health. The Brain Bar pours coffee and juices sweetened with raw honey – no processed sugar in sight.
Chinatown restaurant from childhood friends reinterpreting the Cantonese food they grew up on. The menu is built for sharing – expect modern takes like salt and pepper chicken served with scallion biscuits.
Intimate cocktail salon from the Eleven Madison Park team, where large murals by Francesco Clemente line the walls. The menu is entirely plant-based: technical cocktails in the lounge and a tasting menu at the nine-seat chef’s counter.
Sleek dining room centered on a twelve-foot wood-fire grill turning out seasonal steaks and seafood. A custom raw bar cart makes the rounds between tables; small stools are even provided for handbags.
Corner diner serving Asian-influenced American classics under the rumble of the Manhattan Bridge. Expect long weekend waits for the honey butter pancakes and chicken katsu club.
Community-focused cafe serving espresso, simple sandwiches, and pastries, with local art covering the walls. Evenings bring a switch to beer and wine, often with live music performances.
Old-fashioned lunch counter dishing up serious comfort food – think house-roasted turkey sandwiches and elaborate layer cakes. The cozy, tiled space gets crowded; expect long lines on weekends.
East Harlem bodega serving the city's original chopped cheese sandwich from a 24-hour grill. Ground beef gets chopped with onions and melted American cheese, then pressed into a hero roll for takeaway only.
Counter-service pizzeria turning out airy square slices with a crisp, caramelized cheese crust. The space is strictly standing-room-only, with wall counters for eating and cheesesteaks that rival the pizza.
